Herbs are the unsung heroes of any kitchen garden, offering fresh flavors, delightful aromas, and even medicinal properties. But if you’re new to herb gardening, you might wonder: should you grow them in pots or plant them directly in the ground? Here’s what you need to know when making your decision.
In this article
Is It Better to Grow Herbs in Pots or in the Ground?
The short answer? It depends on your needs and setup. Both methods have their advantages, and the choice largely comes down to factors like mobility, climate, soil, and how much effort you’re willing to put into maintenance.
Here’s a quick breakdown:
- Pots: Perfect for small spaces, beginners, and herbs that require specific conditions. Pots allow for easy mobility and control over soil quality but may need more frequent watering.
- In the Ground: Best for gardeners with plenty of outdoor space and herbs that thrive in natural, well-draining soil. Ground planting often results in bigger, more robust plants but can be harder to manage in areas with poor soil or extreme weather.
How to Decide Where to Grow Herbs
Choosing between pots and the ground involves evaluating your gardening environment and personal preferences. Consider these factors:
- Available Space: If you’re working with a small patio, balcony, or indoor setup, pots are your best bet. For larger gardens, planting in the ground might be more practical.
- Climate Control: Herbs in pots can easily be moved indoors during cold weather or extreme heat, giving you more control over their growing conditions. On the other hand, herbs in the ground are more exposed to environmental stressors.
- Soil Quality: Poor soil? No problem! Pots allow you to create the perfect growing medium for your herbs. If you have nutrient-rich, well-draining garden soil, planting in the ground can save you the hassle of buying potting mix.
- Watering Needs: Potted herbs dry out faster than those in the ground, so they’ll need more frequent watering. Ground-planted herbs benefit from natural moisture retention, especially in mulched beds.
- Mobility: Want to follow the sun or bring your herbs inside during a storm? Pots offer unmatched flexibility. Ground-planted herbs, however, are there to stay.
TO TIP: If you’re unsure, try a combination of both methods. Grow perennial herbs, like thyme and oregano, in the ground for long-term success, and keep tender or finicky herbs, like basil and cilantro, in pots for easy care.
Herbs That Grow Best in the Ground
Some herbs thrive when they’re given room to spread and grow naturally in the soil. These include:
- Thyme: A hardy perennial that loves well-draining soil and full sun. Perfect for garden beds or as a ground cover.
- Oregano: Another perennial that spreads quickly, making it ideal for creating lush herb patches.
- Sage: A drought-tolerant herb that loves being planted in garden soil.
- Mint: While it can grow in pots, mint thrives when planted in the ground—just be sure to contain its spread with barriers, as it’s highly invasive.
- Chives: These hardy herbs grow well in the ground and come back year after year with minimal care.
Herbs That Grow Best in Pots
Certain herbs perform better in pots, especially those that need specific conditions or are prone to overgrowth. Consider growing the following in containers:
- Basil: This tender herb is sensitive to cold and thrives in pots where its environment can be controlled.
- Cilantro: With its short growing season, cilantro does well in pots that allow for quick replanting.
- Parsley: A biennial herb that benefits from the controlled conditions of a pot.
- Rosemary: While it can grow in the ground, rosemary loves the excellent drainage pots provide, especially in humid climates.
- Lemongrass: This tropical herb grows beautifully in pots, allowing you to move it indoors during colder months.
The Bottom Line
So, should you grow herbs in pots or in the ground? It all depends on your space, climate, and the herbs you want to grow. Pots offer flexibility, mobility, and control, making them ideal for beginners, small spaces, or tender herbs. Ground planting, on the other hand, is perfect for hardy, fast-growing herbs and gardeners with plenty of outdoor space.
For the best of both worlds, try a mixed approach. Experiment with different setups and find what works best for your garden. No matter where you grow them, herbs are a rewarding addition to any gardening journey!
